How Do I Know If My Website Is Actually Bringing In Business?

The short answer

A website that is working produces a steady number of phone calls, form leads, and quote requests that you can count every month. The simplest way to know is to ask every new customer how they found you, and to count the calls and form emails that come from the site. Three free Google tools (Google Business Profile, Google Search Console, and Google Analytics) fill in the rest.

You do not need a marketing degree or a monthly report full of charts. You need a handful of numbers, written down once a month, so you can see whether the site is pulling its weight or just sitting there.

What one question should I ask every new customer?

Ask this, every time, on the first call: 'How did you hear about us?' If they say Google, ask one follow-up: 'Did you find our website, or the map listing?' That one habit tells you more than most analytics dashboards, because it comes straight from the person who is about to pay you.

Keep a simple tally sheet by the phone or in a shared note on your phone. Columns for Google search, Google map listing, website, referral or word of mouth, repeat customer, Yelp or Angi, mailer, and other. Put a mark in one column for each new lead. At the end of the month, add them up.

If you have a front desk person or a dispatcher, make it part of their call script. Say a homeowner in Westerville calls about a furnace that will not start. Before the appointment gets booked, the dispatcher asks the question and marks the sheet. It takes five seconds and after three months you have real proof, one way or the other.

Which numbers actually matter for a small business website?

For an owner, only a few numbers connect directly to money. These are the ones worth tracking:

• Phone calls that came from the website, either from your tally sheet or from a call tracking number.
• Form submissions and quote requests, which you can count from the emails your contact form sends you.
• Calls and direction requests from your Google Business Profile, the listing that shows up on Google Maps.
• The searches you show up for in Google Search Console, especially ones that describe your service and area, like 'water softener installation Dublin Ohio'.
• Website clicks from your Google Business Profile, which show how many map searchers went on to look at your site.

Which numbers can I mostly ignore?

Raw visitor counts are the number most SEO reports lead with, and they are the least useful to you. Ten thousand visitors from people in other states looking up a definition do nothing for a remodeler in Gahanna. Two hundred visitors from people in Central Ohio searching for your service can fill your calendar.

Bounce rate (the share of people who leave after one page) sounds important but is not much use to an owner. Someone who lands on your contact page, taps your phone number, and calls you counts as a bounce. Social media likes and follower counts are in the same category. They feel good, but they do not tell you whether the phone rang. If a vendor sends you a report that is all visitors and likes with no mention of calls or leads, that is worth asking about.

Where do I find each of these numbers?

Google Business Profile is your free listing on Google Search and Maps. Search your business name on Google while signed in to the Google account that manages it, and you will see a Performance section showing calls, direction requests, and website clicks over the last few months.

Google Search Console is a free tool from Google that shows which searches your website appeared for, how often it showed up, and how many people clicked. Log in, open the Performance report, and look at the list of queries. If you have never set it up, your web person can usually do it in under half an hour.

Google Analytics is a free tool that counts visits and, if it is set up properly, can count form submissions and taps on your phone number. It is useful, but for most small businesses the tally sheet and form emails answer the main question first.

If you want exact call counts, call tracking is an option. A call tracking service gives you a separate phone number that forwards to your real line and counts every call. The safe way to do it is to keep your main business number on your Google Business Profile and other listings, and show the tracking number only to website visitors. Changing your main number across the web can confuse Google about who you are, which can hurt your local rankings.

A 15-minute monthly check

Pick the first Monday of each month, put it on the calendar, and do the same steps in the same order. Fill out your contact form yourself and confirm the email arrives. Add up last month on the tally sheet. Count the form emails and quote requests. Write down the Google Business Profile calls, direction requests, and website clicks. Open Search Console and note total clicks and the top ten searches.

Write those numbers in one row of a spreadsheet or a notebook, one row per month. That is the whole routine. After six months, you will see a trend that no single month can show you, and you will have something concrete to hand anyone who claims your SEO is working.

Red flags that mean something is wrong

A few patterns show up again and again when I look at websites for Columbus business owners. Any one of them is worth looking into:

• Zero form submissions for months. Test your own form today. Forms break quietly after updates, and the emails they send often land in spam, so leads may be arriving and nobody is reading them.
• Traffic is going up but calls are not. People are finding the site and leaving, which usually points to a slow site, a buried phone number, or a page that does not say clearly what you do.
• Almost every search in Search Console is your own business name. That means people who already know you are finding you, but new customers searching for your service are not.
• A vendor who cannot or will not show you calls, form leads, or Search Console data after several months of paid SEO.

That third red flag is the most common one I see. If nearly every search that reaches your site is your own name, Google is not showing you to new customers in Hilliard, Grove City, or Worthington who search for what you do. Fixing that is the job of local SEO that gets you found by people who have never heard of you.

What does a reasonable result look like?

The honest answer is that it varies a lot by industry, service area, and how competitive your field is. An HVAC company covering all of Central Ohio and a specialty industrial supplier selling to a few dozen buyers will see very different numbers, and both can be doing well. I would rather not give you a benchmark that does not fit your business.

The better comparison is cost per lead. Take what you spend on the website and SEO in a month and divide it by the leads it produced. Then do the same for your other marketing: Yelp ads, Google Ads, mailers, home show booths. If the website brings in leads at a cost close to or below your other options, it is working. If you cannot put a number on it at all, start with the tally sheet this month.

Frequently asked